Let’s conclude this series on strategy in Chinese medicine with our final two points.

Treating Erratically

Martin Luther once said that Mankind is like a drunkard who upon falling off his horse on one side overcompensates and promptly falls off the other side. In Chinese medicine, the opposite of sticking with the same protocol no matter the situation is constantly changing what you’re doing. Now, I want to draw an important distinction here. The speed with which you have to make adjustments will depend on many factors, especially the modality being used. The very nature of acupuncture is such that you’re both creating and reacting to changes in the patient’s energy field, which by its nature is subtle. This just naturally leads to treatments in most cases being completely different from week to week in a lot of patients.

In the case of herbs however, what you don’t want to do with a chronic case if you can possibly help it is to leap from formula to formula. If you have legitimately resolved a layer of the condition and are ready to move to the next thing, that’s one thing. What you don’t want to do however is “Ok this week I think I’ll give you You Gui Wan because last week I gave you Si Jun Zi Tang and the week before I gave you Xiao Yao Wan, so I feel like we’re covering all the bases.” As I have heard Heiner Fruehauf eloquently state, you have to have the courage to decide on a base formula that adequately meets the conditions and then stick with it long term by regularly alternating a small amount of the ingredients.

That said, I don’t want to discourage anyone from having the courage to take a well-calculated risk when they aren’t 100% sure of the outcome. Let’s be honest, not many of us are completely sure about exactly what’s going to happen every time they hand their patient a bottle. I certainly am not. In fact, I find myself white-knuckling the patient’s chart, re-re-checking my conclusion long after they’ve gone home more than I care to admit. Its part of the Chinese medicine experience in our age, in my opinion.

In short, treat what you see and not according to pre-conceived notions if you can possibly help it. When in doubt, remember Reynolds’ First Maxim!

Too Many Doctors Spoil the Case

A huge problem in Chinese medicine-and one not easily resolved-that you will run into with many of your patients is the fact that you are only one of a small army of medical practitioners that they are currently seeing, and often the last one to the party, so to speak. You will often find yourself having to cope with not only the patient’s original condition, but also the added side effects and pulse-obscuring properties of drugs given to them by their team of MDs, the pile of supplements procured from their local health food store, their ill-advised Medifast diet/candida cleanse/detox protocol, their equally ill-advised weight room habit, their Reiki practitioner, their support group, and oh yes, their OTHER acupuncturist. Different doctors I’ve talked to have had different things to say on this subject. Dr. Leon Hammer has said that he typically suggests that if the patient would like to try these other methods that perhaps they come back after having first exhausted their possibilities. A famous Taiwanese doctor that a couple of my friends learned under is reputed to have refused treatment to patients who were currently under the care of someone else. How you handle this is your business of course, but suffice it to say that the more factors there are in the treater equation the more difficult it’s going to be to get anywhere with the case.

In America at least, most of the people who seek us out are in a high degree of physical and energetic chaos. The nature of our societal demands such as our crazy “rest is for the weak” work ethic, our fetishization of requiring the absolute best of the best of everything we come into contact with, keeping up with not just the Joneses anymore but the rich, famous, and Hollywood-employed as well, our terrible diets, our masochistic exercise programs, our sense of entitlement and lack of tradition, our rejection of the old and glorification of the young, our out and out INSANITY in every corner of our existence produces a patient who is coming apart at the seams on their best day. The introduction of any more chaos whatsoever into this picture can cause nothing but further catastrophe. It is absolutely not surprising that our most common “big” diseases are cancer and autoimmune conditions. We are chaos personified, the absolute opposite of peaceful growth and progression like the seasons. Nearly every patient that walks through our doors will be in this state and it would be well to keep in mind.

Also worth noting is that the primary problem in the chaotic state is that the very Yin and Yang of our beings is separating and with that separation comes greater and greater vulnerability to more disastrous diseases of every sphere. In my opinion, this separation begins at the level of the Gui Zhi Tang-type Taiyang invasion (note that Gui Zhi Tang’s most famous characteristic is that of “harmonizing Ying and Wei” which is nothing less than putting Yin and Yang back into contact with each other) and ends in death. Everything else along that continuum is some degree of separation of Yin and Yang and needs to be accounted for thusly. I fervently recommend that anyone not intimately familiar with this concept read the following article by Dr. Hammer entitled,” Towards a Unified Theory of Chronic Disease with Regard to the Separation of Yin and Yang and ‘The Qi is Wild.”

How do these two topics relate to timing and momentum? Simple. If you’re trying to walk to Albuquerque you’ll never get there if you walk toward Portland for a day, then San Diego for a day, then Atlanta for two days. You also won’t get there if you ask directions from everyone you meet and they all tell you something different. Timing and momentum is doing the right things at the right time consistently. Cure doesn’t happen without it.

That concludes this series. I hope you’ve gotten something useful out of it. If you’d like to go back and read the previous segments, here they are again:

http://deepesthealth.com/2010/strategy-in-chinese-medicine-timing-and-momentum-pt-1/

http://deepesthealth.com/2010/strategy-in-chinese-medicine-timing-and-momentum-pt-2/

http://deepesthealth.com/2010/strategy-in-chinese-medicine-timing-and-momentum-pt-3/

Strategy in Chinese Medicine, pt 4: Timing and Momentum

Related articles

• Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 3 (2)
• Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 1 (6)
• Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 2 (1)

The past two weeks we’ve been discussing timing as it pertains to acupuncture and herbology. Let’s now tackle momentum.

As you may recall, the quote we have been referencing from the Art of War is this:

“When a falcon strike breaks the body of its prey, it is because of timing. When torrential water tosses boulders, it is because of momentum.”

What Sun Zi is talking about here is the accomplishing of something difficult, moving mountains as it were. In Chinese medicine this can be compared to dealing with difficult and intractable cases, the likes of which unfortunately are rapidly increasing in number here in the U.S. These cases are often created by incorrect or ineffectual treatment of a condition that is made orders of magnitude more complicated by the failed treatment itself. Here I’m talking about things like disease suppression, medication side effects, and the results of surgery, all things that most of our patients will have experienced in spades before they ever walk through our doors as their “last hope”. Leaving aside for now the problems of what to attack and how (something I’ll cover at a later date), let’s now assume that we have intervened in some way and had some sort of positive effect on the patient. This is where momentum comes in.

Consecutive intervention

The process is almost always going to be the same for deciding on treatment: gather the symptoms, look at the whole picture, make a decision. The next time the patient comes in this decision-making process has to be repeated. Even if the decision is to continue the treatment from the previous session, you’re still having to make the call of “what do they need me to do right now?” The time-honored TCM school clinic technique of “I did these points last week and they feel better so I’m just gonna do them again” is just not going to fly unless a proper examination reveals that yes, that combination of points is appropriate here. This is the primary component of establishing momentum, doing the right thing at the right time, repeated.

Uprooting

Borrowing from the Chinese martial art Taijiquan: in Taijiquan, a primary goal is to “uproot” your opponent (meaning, remove their structural stability) so that you can basically do whatever you want with them. My teacher’s teacher once compared this to a job he used to work at a loading dock in a harbor in Taiwan moving giant barrels from ship to land and vice versa. By themselves, the barrels were absolutely impossible for even 2-3 people to move. Yet, if you uprooted it by tilting it up onto its edge a bit you could now sort of roll it by yourself to wherever you needed it to go.

Treating chronic disease is very much like this. Your first task is to make enough initial headway against the condition that now it starts responding to what you want to do, which I can tell you is not always the easiest thing in the world. However, once you finally achieve that uprooting, now you have to keep it uprooted so that you can keep pushing it where you want it to go, like the aforementioned barrels. Explaining what to do to achieve this would take its own series, and really is the sum of all other treatment knowledge you are able to bring to bear. So instead I will tell you what not to do, otherwise known as a group of pitfalls that will effectively kill whatever momentum you have built. Note that some of these pitfalls will be of your doing and some will be of your patients’ doing. It’s part of your job to make clear to them what needs to happen in order for the desired result to be achieved, meaning achieving health.

Pitfall #1-Failing to modify

Something that is abundantly clear in Western medicine that somehow we in Chinese medicine lose sight of is the idea of habituation. A short explanation of this phenomenon is this: when the exact same treatment-of any kind-is repeated enough, the body or the agents of disease will adapt to it making the treatment no longer effective. This can actually be viewed from a couple different viewpoints. One is that the patient is rarely in the exact same situation two visits in a row (“you can never step in the same river twice”), especially where acupuncture is concerned. Another is that if you are dealing with an intelligent pathogenic agent (virus, bacteria, spirochete, etc.) if you continually show it the same attack it will eventually adapt, making the attack ineffective. Think MRSA.

This is fairly easy to deal with in acupuncture, as you can throw in subtle variations to the treatment that meet the patient exactly where they are at that moment in very specific detail. With herbs it’s more difficult as in these types of cases you’ll need the same formula for months at a time. The key to this then is having a good enough grasp of your root formulas and also of the nature of your individual herbs so that you can switch in and out appropriate substitutions that still get you where you want to go. Now obviously, no two herbs are a perfect trade for each other as even different parts of the same plant behave very differently and have very different properties. In the context of a carefully modified formula, however, the structure that is not changed will help keep what has been changed moving in the right direction.

This concept is most vitally important for cases where there is an organism on the other end that is being dealt with as part of the process (like Lyme Disease for instance), but this also holds true for other deep diseases, though you may not need to rotate as often. In a fast-reacting case (like Lyme) I generally look to rotate ingredients every three weeks or so. I usually look to rotate major (and powerful) components of the base formula I’m using that I’m confident I can get a good trade for. So if the base formula is Gui Zhi Tang, I would have the option to rotate just about any ingredient in the formula. Rou Gui for Gui Zhi, Gan Jiang or Pao Jiang for Sheng Jiang, Chi Shao for Bai Shao, Gan Cao for Zhi Gan Cao. In this particular case I would probably only rotate two ingredients (unless I had a very good reason for doing otherwise-always a caveat!) and try to stick to the soul of the formula by changing Gui Zhi less frequently than the other ingredients. Obviously this applies to any formula that you could use long-term. Note that in some cases (and with some patients) you’ll need to rotate more frequently or more creatively, with other cases you can get away with longer waits. Your mileage will vary.

If you fall into the pitfall of failing to modify you will certainly see the case stall out, which can mean not only a simply stalling of progress but can frequently be the first step into a quick regression depending on what else is going on in the patient’s life. You want to avoid this at all costs.

Next week we’ll discuss the pitfalls of Treating Erratically and Too Many Doctors Spoil the Case.

Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 3

Related articles

• Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 1 (6)
• Strategy in Chinese Medicine, pt 4: Timing and Momentum (3)
• Strategy in Chinese Medicine: Timing and Momentum, pt. 2 (1)